Flawed assessments

The issues facing Obama are daunting. The reams of paperwork submitted to him describe very different Afghanistans and very different Pakistan. Every author of every assessment has an agenda. For example the Generals in the field go for the obvious–more soldiers. This is what happened in Korea and in Afghanistan. What else can a general ask for to hide his failures. He can ask for more troops and he can try to shift the blame on the neighboring countries. Every American military defeat in the past two centuries was blamed on the neighbors. Korea was blamed on the Chinese and the Russians; Vietnam was blamed on the Chinese and on Cambodia. According to American dogma the “Ho Chi Minh” was the culprit for the incompetence of the government in Saigon, and the Chinese were to blame for the inadequacy of the US soldiers who really didn’t want to fight in “Nam”. Today the same issues have surfaced in Afghanistan. The US general are asking for more soldiers and blaming Pakistan for their failures. Today more than Afghanistan has been lost to the anti-occupation forces.

Afghan Surge: McChrystal malarkey hides incompetence of NATO, ISAF & US forces McChrystal right on India: Delhi must scale back Afghan operations

Admiral Mullen is still wrong The crusty specious, Admiral is mistaken about Afghanistan. Of course General McChrystal and Admiral Mullen will ask for more troops and blame Pakistan for their failures. They will use language that blames others. The Taliban control all of Afghanistan–why would need a safe haven in Pakistan.

We are running the risk of replicating the fate of the Soviets” Mr. Brzezinski Brzezinski: Don’t start new wars. Use diplomacy in Pakistan

The other assessment was at least chaperoned by the Neoconish Bruce Reidel brought in by the White House Chief of staff Mr. Rahm Embanuel who served for two years in the IDF and whose father lives in Israel. It is obvious that Mr. Reidel’s assessment would be tainted by neocon thought which puts Pakistan is a black spot.

Hillary Clinton is influenced by the Bharati black majic and wants to use Pakistan allied with India as a buffer towards China. She is so anomored with this idea that she doesn’t realise that she has lost all credebaility as an honest broker in Pakistan. Clinton reads Pakistani sites: Unable to shed false Neocon concocted “clichés

Pakistan: Hillary Clinton still doesn’t have a clue

Pakistan: Why Ms. Clinton doesn’t get it Hillary Clinton admits to US support for Bin Laden & creation of Taliban

Richard Holbrooke has been on the fence, blames Pakistan and hasn’t quite found his niche.

Mr. Biden is a realist, and suggested a major withdrawal from Afghanistan.Can the drama of a Joe Biden’s “resignation” end the Afghan war fiasco?

  • Chomsky sees no change in US foreign policy under Obama
  • Afghanistan: US propping up an another dictator again
  • Why is it taking President Obama so long to decide what to do in Afghanistan? There are a lot of reasons, a few good, but most are the consequence of past mistakes.

    The first is the sheer amount of information pouring into the White House, from the State Department, the Pentagon and Afghanistan. It is beyond the ability of any single person to read it all, said one who is witness to the flood.

    That is a result not just of the deteriorating situation — as General Stanley McChrystal described it in his analysis — but of the White House having paid too little attention before Mr Obama gave his supposedly definitive statement of strategy in the spring. That was based on an analysis by Bruce Riedel, a former CIA officer, but lacked detailed knowledge of conditions on the ground and was more of a compilation of different views than a tight argument.

    A second inhibition is the “2009 problem”: the US has more than doubled troop numbers this year but has little to show for it. That has held Mr Obama back from embracing General McChrystal’s call for 40,000 more troops. Many advisers support General McChrystal’s plan to train tens of thousands more Afghan police and soldiers as the only plausible way towards an exit.

    Bluster before exit: US capitulates to Afghan Taliban: Negotiating retreat schedule

    The silent “K” in Holbrooke’s portfolio

    Brown in troop threat to Karzai

    But they are sceptical that the training can be accelerated as General McChrystal maintains. That doubt is supported by one policeman’s lethal attack on British soldiers this week.

    Two US reports on training in September painted a bleak picture of the quality of Afghan recruits despite the $19 billion the US has spent since 2001.

    The elections also proved a paralysing catastrophe. They left President Karzai as the winner, perched atop a Government whose nationwide reputation for fraud was only enhanced by its conduct of the polls. The US also needs to decide what to do with a collection of warlords and local powerbrokers whom it has paid to hunt the Taleban and Osama bin Laden, but who are widely resented.

    British politicians and officers have told the White House increasingly directly that public support is falling while the President mulls over what to do. But although Americans’ support for the war is falling too, the anger, grief and open challenge to the strategy have not reached the levels in Britain. “We need time to get this right,” will be the theme of Mr Obama’s announcement.

    Tick Tock Tick Tock-2011: Obama’s shrinking Afghan timeline Truth not Orwellian propaganda: Best article on Afghanistan anywhere

    His aides have agreed on one point: there is no “right” answer. They are trying to craft options for him, to “give him some space” to amend his policy again, when he finally does decide what it is. UK Times. From The Times November 7, 2009, Obama wants more time on Afghanistan, but it is running out fast Bronwen Maddox: World Briefing

    US bluff: Other arduous US Supply Chain routes to Afghanistan not feasible

    Afghanistan fiasco: Cleaning up the Am-Brit failures in Kabul again

    Solutions to “Obama’s Vietnam”–AfPak

    David Kilcullen incessant paranoid hallucinating Pakistanphobic rhetoric destroys his credibility Obama must avoid creating a backlash in neighboring Pakistan by heavy-handed U.S. military intervention there: David Kilcullen

    Can Obama pull US out of the Afghan quicksand? Choosing China & Pakistan over Bharat (aka India)

    NATO not buying the Obama Doctrine or surge after Surge?

    Afghanistan & Pakistan: Can the US Prevail? No!

    Fixing Afpak: Inability to define exit strategy spells inevitable US military catastrophe in Kabul Obama’s sane policy lost? Negotating with the Taliban Betrayals, blackmail in Bakiyev cloaking failure as success hiding the defeat declaring victory withdrawing from Afghanistan within 12 months

    Obama’s new policy was supposed to be a Marshal Plan & end to bombing raids in Pakistan

    Convincing the US tin ear of the Pakistani point of view

    Rahm Emanuel blames the “Ho Chi Minh Trail” for Afghan defeat

    Obama’s Neocon: Bruce Riedel’s rancid racism against Pakistan Are bigoted Bruce Riedel’s diatribes still valid for Pakistan & Afghanistan? Mr. Bruce Riedel’s irrational rhetoric exacerbates US-Pakistani relations

    Growing consensus in the Obama team: Much of Pakistan’s problems originate in Afghanistan

    Obama advisor Weinbaum focus on talks & Reconciliation got lost in blood and gore.

    Ahmed Rashid’s bad advice about Pakistan Afghanistan: Did Ahmed Rashid sell the American down the river?

    Afghan Surge fiasco: Ahmed Rashid’s bad advice
    Obama adviser insights into Afghan policy: Result same old same old

    Why troops surges in Afghanistan are doomed to failure?

    Rand report: End GWOT. Defeat Al-Qaeda with police & Dollars Hindu Kush Curtain Call: The End Game in Afghanistan Harvard questions: Afghanistan Lost? Barnett Rubin & Maleeha Lodhi solutions to quagmire The Pakistani perspective: Peace deals only way to precipitate face saving for US & Obama’s smooth Exit strategy from Afghanistan

    After NATO rejection Obama has few options left in Afghanistan Pakistan First by Shireen Mazari: The devastating affects of appeasing India and kowtowing to the USA

    Pakistan to US: No pay-No play: Tough lessons in geography!

    People talk glibly of ‘the total disarmament of the frontier tribes’ as being the obvious policy…but to obtain it would be as painful and as tedious an undertaking as to extract the stings of a swarm of hornets, with naked fingers.” Winston Churchill

    PEANUTS: Puny US Aid to Pakistan is too little too late. Marshall Plan, & Trade concessions missing

    Graveyard of Empires: AfPak-TurkTaj-UzbKaz-AzKyr -istan Obama’s “Vietnam”: Khyber & Hindu Kush

    Afghanistan:– Pakistan’s Eminent Domain

    India’s dark shadow on Afghanistan

    Comments are closed.

    Categories

    Archives