Why Malaysia retired Mig-29s & India didn’t

Posted on November 3, 2009 by Moin Ansari

Replacement of Malaysian MiG-29 Faces Future Budget Challenges


The MiG-29Ns are to be replaced by the ‘Multi Role Combat Aircraft’.

08:23 GMT, November 2, 2009 The Malaysian Government has indicated that it intends to retire its entire fleet of MiG-29N interceptors by the end of 2010. The government is expected to save RM260 million ($75.68 million, €51.30 million) annually by phasing out the aircraft. Defence Minister Datuk Seri Dr Ahmad Zahid Hamidi said the money saved would be utilised to pay for the maintenance of other aircraft and systems which were still being used in the Royal Malaysian Air Force (RMAF).

He said the MiG-29N fighter jets would be phased out as it was difficult and costly to maintain some old components and systems for the fighter jets.
“The weaponry for the fighter jets has reached the end of its lifespan and extending the lifespan would be costly and would not be viable,” he told Parliament. Ahmad Zahid said this when replying to Datuk Abdul Rahman Dahlan (BN-Kota Belud) who wanted to know the rationale in phasing out the Russian-made MiG-29N jet fighters.

The minister said the RMAF planned to replace the MiG-29N fighter jets with the ‘Multi Role Combat Aircraft’ (MRCA) for air operations. “After the MiG-29N fighter jets have been phased out, their role would be carried out by the Sukhoi SU-30MKM which is among the most sophisticated long-range fighter jets,” he said.

The MiG-29N aircraft played the role of interceptor jets and 18 of the fighter jets were purchased for the RMAF in 1993. However, two of the aircraft crashed in 1998 and 2005.

The Malaysian decision marks the “end of an era”, as Malaysia was the first non-Soviet block country to acquire Russian combat aircraft. Malaysia is now expected to float a request for proposal (RFP) for 18 new-generation fighter aircraft to replace the MiG-29Ns. This may take the form of long-expected follow-on order for a second batch of F/A-18s (these would now be in the SUPER HORNET version), but thinking in Kuala Lumpur appears to be in favour of an open tender. Circulation of the RFP is expected sometimes next year after completion of a study on the Royal Malaysian Air Force’s fighter requirements. It seems likely that all major combat aircraft manufactures will be invited to submit their bids. Given the current emphasis on bolstering its indigenous defence industry, Malaysia would probably include not only the usual request for offsets, but also technology transfer and industrial partnership clauses.

In the meantime, Russia’s state arms exporter Rosoboronexport has already offered to buy back the remaining 16 MiG-29Ns and in turn supply the RMAF with a follow-on batch of six Su-30MKMs at what is described as a “fair price”.

The RMAF’s plans for the purchase of a new fleet of fighter aircraft are, however, facing very serious financial obstacles. The global economic downturn appears to have been a damper for the Malaysian defence procurement. Since 2008, Kuala Lumpur has been careful not to announce any major orders but rather proceed with ongoing commitments. The defence procurement budget is under strain, as the government focuses on economic recovery.

The 10th Five-Year Malaysian Plan (2011-1015), which is to the submitted to Parliament in June 2010, is expected to propose procurement and development funding to the tune of RM7 billion (some $1.6 billion) for the entire defence and security sector, with some RM5 billion being allocated for defence proper. It is further understood that nearly half the total amount will be invested in order to replenish war stocks (missiles, bombs and ammunition), with relatively little money being left for new procurement efforts. Also, at least 30 per cent of the available money will be reserved for purchases from the national defence industry. Clearly enough there is no way the purchase of 18 new-generation aircraft could be financed under these conditions. http://www.defpro.com/daily/details/438/
—-
By Dr. Ezio Bonsignore, Editor-in-Chief of MILITARY TECHNOLOGY (MILTECH). Comment by Dr. Ezio Bonsignore, Editor-in-Chief of MILITARY TECHNOLOGY 

Indian duds in Pokhran: Dr. Santhanam exposes nuclear fizzle ‘Naked’ India needs Nuclear tests to deal with China: Santhanam Indian Army chief Malik unsure about Nukes doubts Kalam The entire Indian establishment has been lying about the Pokhran duds for a decade India’s Pokhran duds blow up 11 years later: Huge political fallout India’s ‘98 Nuclear duds complicate 123 deal with USA and CTBT signing

The Delhi Dud Report video

How Abdul Kalam stole US secrets for Delhi’s rockets

Indian “Nuclear Sub” not “Nuclear”: Sailing empty hull without reactor Rust bucket Arihant: Delhi’s clunky, noisy Soviet era Charlie class tub assembled from Russian submarine kit India’s Bullock Cart Space program Made in USA & Russia More Duds: The fiasco of the IAFs Mig 29s The Delhi Dud Report on Indian Defense: Arms that don’t work Rust bucket Arihant: Delhi’s clunky, noisy Soviet era Charlie class tub assembled from Russian submarine kit Delhi Duds: The fiasco of the IAFs Mig 29s

The Delhi Dud Report on Indian Defense: Arms that don’t work

Indian Tejas Light Combat Aircraft (LCA), continues to falter even after 25 years Tejas 1983: A dismal failure which became obsolete in the design phase

Helicopters for India?

The Admiral Gorshkov ripoff

How Abdul Kalam Stole US secrets for Delhi’s rockets Delhi’s Tejas World Record: 500th Flying coffin crashes Russian FGFA: Tricolor paint

More Flying coffins?

$10 billion for which plane?

F-16s or F-35s

Lockheed’s bait and switch

Moscow sale to Delhi: Russian Mig 35s are simply Mig 29s with new decals

Delhi’s missiles Brahmos: Faster than the speeding bullet Abject failure in indigenous arms production forced Delhi to buy weapons without Transfer of Technology

After Moscow’s grounding, when will Delhi ground the New Flying Coffins?

Delhi’s deeply frozen Israeli Missiles: Windfall profits for Delhi politicians but no Baraks

Unmitigated failure: Indian Tejas scrapped. New Snecma plane?

Aircraft Carrier “Admiral Gorshkov”: Delhi wanted a Lada, & now demands a Mercedes

More Flying coffins?

$10 billion for which plane?

F-16s or F-35s

Lockheed’s bait and switch

Moscow sale to Delhi: Russian Mig 35s are simply Mig 29s with new decals

Delhi’s missiles

Brahmos: Faster than the speeding bullet

Abject failure in indigenous arms production forced Delhi to buy weapons without Transfer of Technology

After Moscow’s grounding, when will Delhi ground the New Flying Coffins?

The CAG Report on Indian duds video

Who is responsible for the duds in the Bharati Defense establishment. VIDEO

Duds in the Bharati Defense establishment. Part II VIDEO

Comedy of errors: IAF bombs Gandhi canal in Jaisalmir-India

If the US can sell Junk jets to Japan why not Bharat?

India’s Nuclear proliferation

India’s inadequate aircraft strength: it is not enough: IAF Chief P V Naik

Indian Space Program stole NASA secrets using Israeli spy

Filed under: Current Affairs, India CA, Politics

« »