6 Responses to “India’s Security nightmares: Naxalites, Kashmir, 7 Sisters & Communalism”

1. rich05 says:

   August 25, 2009 at 9:56 am

   hi guys

   this is my first blog on this site i have been reading articles on this site last 4/5 days and i have found thos site quite anti indian i mean in india too the press is quite ani pakistan but hers ita little too much that even a pakistani reading it will think twice before beleiving it

   at least the educated who have acess to other news channels from other countries,
   the me moin articles take the cake

   now regarding the above article yes whatever is been said is true to a little extent not as bad as been written

   , every article says the dalit are slaughtered ect in india yes they face a lot of problem but not as the article suggest if that waas the case there would have been a civil war, as per your papaer the constitute 450 millin peopls
   then muslim problem like the pak beleives they are beeing killed indiscrinetly ect ect they are 200 million

   christioan are ben burnet alive ect 30 million people

   sikhc third class citizen and dicrminated agaist 30 million peopls

   NE atated the 7 sisters aroung another 30 million

   jains now problem with them 20 million ppl

   then the tamils revolt as your papers says 60 million

   this makes 820 million people now they are all against the indian union and in return are killied and slaughtered and in return they are revolting in against the govt and killing the indian soulders and policemen and its is total chaos in indian

   the above constitute almost 70% of the population

   now my question is this can the balace hindus do waht pakistan suggest control all the others

   i leave it to you to make the calculations

   yes we have problems but nothing serious that it cannot be managed

   now a little details

   our PM is a sikh
   the president of the most powerful party is catholic
   dalit is the cheif minister of the most powerful state whose population is more then pakistan Uthar Pradesh
   a dalit is also the speaker of the house
   the govet at present is formed with the support of the Tamil parties at the centre

   we have the higest economic growthe in the world after China will itbe possible if we had problem as pakistan insistes we have

   the military is made of every cast creed and religion
   christian form 4% of the force, sikhs 5%, muslims 3%dalits 40% NE makes 2 % tamils 4%, we even have kashmiri muslims all this make more then 60%
   is it possible to have an army with so many people from oppressed class and still opress and kill and rape them, thee above figurs is also the same in the police force, the persentace is slightly different

   well now you guys can do the maths of what is possible nadbollywood, the

   now look at boolywood, our space programme, or IT export, our balance of payment siyuation, or foreingh exchage reserves our expediture on education and defence ect
   and then you will know if we are a failed states as the article implies or a sucessful democracy with lots of problem

   and unlike pakistan we have no ristriction on who can hold the higest office in the land
   we had

   3 muslim presedent
   sikh president
   dalit speakers 2, christian and shikh comander in cheif of the army, muslims chief ministers, top muslim indrialist the richest man in india Mr AZIM, to actors are musilms ect ect

   well if we have all this there maybe something india is doing right

   what do you guys say

   cheers

   Richie Rodrigues

   Reply
   • Moin Ansari says:

     August 25, 2009 at 11:44 am

     Inabaility to read any criticism of Bharat says a lot about the temple education there. Here we go again, the brainwashed children of the Hindu Mahasab begin repeating the same of same old.

     So le me get this… just because a token Myawati is (s)elected in the UP–this absolves everyoneone to continue to enslave 450 million Dalits and Sudras

     Just becuase there is a token Catholic has been (s)elected then the murder nad arson in Orrisa is forgotten.

     This is convulated logic

     Please visit the Khalistan sites as well as the Dalit Freedom Network to see how the minorities feel. Watch the stories about the Naxals to see thier lot. Tokenism may be good for PR but doesn’t prove anything. Electing Azad as president of Indian National Congress (INC) did not get the INC the Muslim vote.

     Tokenism does not wish away the Untouchability, the massacre of 10 million girls before and after brith

     Reply
2. Subbu says:

   April 22, 2010 at 7:59 am

   I totally agree with Richie Rodrigues. This website is genuinely an anti-India. Iet it be. But, depicting such stories or rather exaggerating such stories is aimed to attract anti-India feelings among Pakistani educated populace and others who by chance happen to view this website. While there are some facts based on publications of our own Indian media reports, this website editor has used for his ‘imaginative stories’. Now, I understand why people of Pakistan hate India so much. Uneducated people are indoctrinated by depicting this untruely events and stories. This is why emotional Muslim people tend to take arms against India by believing such fabricated stories.
   I request the editor of this website and the contributor of these article (stories), please come India and see for yourself what is India and how Indian people live in peace. Every country has their own problem.But the degree varies. Our own body has problems no one is perfect. Likewise no country is perfect. We can proudly say India is a secular democracy and a rising power in the region behind China. But, go to China and see for yourself what kind of political system they have. and what kind of human rights they get. Without democracy and human rights China will never be a great country.
   Pakistan controlled by its own religious rules and laws will never be in par with the ‘Great India’. Please instead envying India try to learn from India that how people of Different ethnicity, language, caste, religion can live in ‘near perfect’ harmony.
   By the way, I myself is a one of above mentioned categories’ minority. And, ther are problems in India as other countries have, but they are not as severe as projected by this website. Plase get out of your anti-India mind set start observing everything objectively. Do not mislead people with your stupid articles.

   Reply
   • The Editors Rupee News says:

     April 22, 2010 at 11:04 am

     We do not accept free advice, specially from people who not use their real names. How many different names will you use “Richie”. Its same old folk who are abusive, nasty have nothing to add, and they keep posting inane flame baits. Their only reaction to the factual reporting– is to blame someone else.

     Bharat is in self-denial.

     The picture that they see in the mirror is so ugly that they refuse to look at it. This a national issue for Bharatis–they learn not to see the poverty and the penury around them. The are incapable of introspection or self-criticism.

     They are in in a delusion of some sort of superpower hallucination. They are very proud of “democracy” but cannot accept the verdict of the 1946 elections. They are proud of elections, but are incapable of accepting another’s point of view.

     The post falls back to their temple indoctrination—stereotyping Muslims, Islam, and hence Pakistan. The bigotry in these posts are not an anomaly–this is a depiction of the ethos of Bharati society. Even educated doctors fall into the same trap of stereotyping all Muslims as emotional and unintelligent.

     As a social experiment, the racism on these posts is a clear indication on the falsehood of Bharati claims of secularism and tolerance. Tokenism cannot be confused with actual parity or balance.

     The sheer weight of Bharati animosity towards China, Pakistan, Nepal, Sikkim, Bhutan, Lanka and even Bangladesh is mind boggling. This attitude keeps Bharat embroiled in petty conflicts which every other country of the world has resolved. Bharat is incapable of resolving the conflicts because of the mentality in comments above.

     Invariably, there is no discussion, only flame baits thrown at the site, and the authors. The irrefutable facts cannot be challenged, many from Bharati sources–so they begin floundering here and there and “what about”. The knee jerk reaction is “what about Pakistan”–as if that would resolve the issue at hand. A demonized neighbor is a great scapegoat–unfortunately it does not solve Bharat’s immense problems.

     We have been to Bharat–I distinctly remember my my impression when I landed in Mumbai and saw people defecating at the airport–not outside–inside the airport

     The train ride also showed people lined up on the train track doing poo poo.

     The first thing I noticed–which I was not prepared for was this wall of unimaginable poverty that hit us–harranged by hundred of beggars, and a throng of can drivers jostling for my fare.

     I saw a vehicle that I had never seen before. They called it a “Cycle rickshaw” where an emaciated man with bones sticking out would pull up to four passengers and take him around town. This was the cheapest transport and thousands used it

     They dilapidated cab–called “Hindustan” was aptly named because it depicted the country. The cab driver drove through an area called “Gharibabad”. Turned out this was where more than half the population of Mumbai lived.

     At night I saw sidewalk full of people sleeping on them, elbowing each other for inches of space. Men, women and children lived on what they called “footpath”. The Pullulating millions sleeping on the sidewalks is the norm in Delhi, Mumbai, Benaras, Lucknow, Kolkota–to put insult to injury–the city charges rents from these poor souls.

     I also remember naked men roaming about wearing nothing but paint on their foreheads–a throwback to the ancient jungle past. It turned out, these were the holy men who got free food and drinks.

     After finishing eating t the Mcdonald, people ran to our table and scraped up the leftovers, and snatched the tray from me–before the guard could get to them

     In Delhi, right next to the Presidential palace, there were rats, cows, and other animals roaming freely on the streets. Cows would stop traffic and o one would move them.

     That is my impression of Incredible India. Nothing Anti-anything about this–we just reported the facts as we saw them

     Reply
3. SHAHNAZ ABDULLA says:

   April 29, 2010 at 5:08 am

   All Pakistanis are day dreaming.India is land of 20 crore Muslims more than Pakistani population.We the Muslims of India faced adverse situation after the partition and still facing.So at any cost at any circumstance we will not allow any further partition of our country.Indian Muslims are safe and enjoyed the democracy for more than sixty years which no other Muslim population can claim.There are problems but the problems can be overcome.You must remember Gateway to Islam to India is not Sindh but Kerala.

   Reply
   • The Editors says:

     April 29, 2010 at 12:38 pm

     Writing under a Muslim name doesn’t fool anyone. The name is also very strange and does not make sense.

     The data in the article is irrefutable. There is nothing “Pakistani” about Justice Sachar.

     We deal with facts on this site. Poetry is nice, but it cannot contradict cold hard data and statistics.

     While the “kam ba ya” song looks great on paper–however the hard facts of the Justice Sachaar Report throw cold water on the “we are family” type of nonsense. The Sachar Report does not agree with the lollypops. Justice Sachaar clearly states that there is deep and profound discrimination against Indian Muslims.

     Statistics and facts are a lot more potent than “opinions” from those who are wrapped up in sweet Tri-Colored flags.

     Justice Rajindar Sachar says the following:

     • The Justice Rajindar Sachar Report which was presented to the Prime Minister on 17 November 2006 and was tabled in Parliament on 30 November 2006 has twelve chapters.
     • GENERAL: “The Muslim community exhibits deficits and deprivation in practically all dimensions of development ”
     • Most of the variables indicate that Muslim-OBCs are significantly deprived in comparison to Hindu-OBCs.
     • POLITICAL PARTICIPATION:.. participation is denied to Muslims through a variety of mechanisms. While it was pointed out that many names of Muslims were missing in the voter lists of a number of states, the Committee’s attention was also drawn to the issue of Muslim concentration
     • that Muslims are being systematically denied political participation. The Committee collected data from all over the country in the light of which the second allegation regarding reservation of constituencies was found to be correct.
     • LITERACY: In the field of literacy the Committee found that the rate among Muslims was far below the national average. The gap between Muslims and the general average is greater in urban areas and women.
     • The disparity in graduation attainment rates is widening since 1970s between Muslims and all other categories in both urban and rural areas. In premier colleges only one out of 25 under-graduate students and one out of 50 post-graduate students is a Muslim. Unemployment rate among Muslim graduates is the highest among all socio-religious communities. Only 3% of Muslim children among the school going age go to Madarsas. There is dearth of facilities for teaching Urdu. Lower enrolment in Urdu medium schools is due to limited availability of such schools at the elementary level.
     • WAGE RATES: Muslim regular workers get lower daily earnings in both public and private jobs compared to other socio-religious communities.
     • LOANS: The average amount of bank loan disbursed to the Muslims is 2/3 of the amount disbursed to other minorities. In some cases it is half.
     • INCOME: Substantially larger proportion of the Muslim households in urban areas are in the less than Rs.500 expenditure bracket.
     • EMPLOYMENT DISCRIMINATION: The presence of Muslims has been found to be only 3% in the IAS, 1.8% in the IFS and 4% in the IPS. The share of Muslims in employment in various departments is abysmally low at all levels. Muslim community has a representation of only 4.5% in Indian Railways while 98.7% of them are positioned at lower levels. Representation of Muslims is very low in the Universities and in Banks. In no state does the representation of Muslims in the government departments match their population share. Their share in police constables is only 6%, in health 4.4%, in transport 6.5%.

     Report of the Prime Minister’s High Level Committee (headed by Justice Rajindar Sachar) on Social, Economic and Educational Status of the Muslim Community of India

     http://www.milligazette.com/dailyupdate/2006/200612141_Sachar_Report_Status_Indian_Muslims.htm

     If you have an issue with the facts presented—please present your own data which is superior to the Sachar Report. The Sachar Report was not contradicted by any Bharati body

     Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Leave a Reply