2009: “Where in The World Is Osama bin Laden?” …someone knows!?

Posted on December 9, 2007 by Moin Ansari


 Noticias de Rupia | Nouvelles de Roupie | Rupiennachrichten | новости рупии | 卢比新闻 | Roepienieuws | Rupi Nyheter | ルピーニュース | Notizie di Rupia | PAKISTAN LEDGER | پاکستاني کھاتا | Moin Ansari | معین آنصآرّی |  اخبار روپیہ |  December 9th, 2007 |

  • 2008: “Where in The World Is Osama bin Laden?” …someone knows!?
  • Hope that the U.S. will get sucked into Pakistan.” Osama bin Laden

    • Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.Where is OBL? This huge question has been subject of a lot of discussion all over the world. We look at a few aspects of the issue that has plagued America for about a decade.

    Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.

     Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.

    The OBL mystery is over of the most vexing question of our time. Can he ever be found? is he dead? How hard is it to find a really really tall man who needs medical attention on an ongoing basis and according to some needs a kidney dialisis machine.

    Osama Bin Laden's mountain hideout

    Osama in K2 mountains?

    LAHORE: Al Qaeda chief Osama Bin Laden is hiding in the Karakoram segment of the Himalayan range, Arabic television network Al-Arabiya quoted its sources as saying on Monday. According to the Dubai-based network, in the past few days United States (US) security and military officials had a top-level summit at a military base in Qatar’s capital Doha to plan an operation to hunt for Osama. US commander in Iraq General David Petraeus and US ambassador to Islamabad Anne Patterson were reported to have attended the summit. Last week, Petraeus testified before a US Congressional committee about security in Iraq and warned that members of Al Qaeda based in Pakistan’s Tribal Areas were planning a new attack on the US. According to the channel, reports say the Central Investigation Agency (CIA) has located Osama in the “rooftop of the world”, the area of Pakistan that borders Afghanistan to the west, in particular the chain of mountains of Afghan province of Nurestan and China to the north.

    The report says that support for Al Qaeda is broadening, not only among the Afghan Taliban and Pakistani tribes that deny Osama’s presence in the area, but also fundamentalists including the Muslim Brotherhood that has changed its strategy. Muslim Brotherhood leader Mahdi Akef has called Osama “a mujahid that sincerely fights against foreign occupation in order to be closer to Allah”. In an interview published on the Arab website, Elaph, Akef said he supported the activities of Al Qaeda against occupiers and not those against the people.

    Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.Certainly the American CIA, the Pakistani ISI, the India RAW, the Afghan “KHAD” and the Russian “KGB” do not know.

    Mums the word from the American administration and CIA. Three mortals have one time or other known where he was. All three journalists have interviewed him

    1. Robert Fisk for the Independent of the UK
    2. Hamid Mir of GEO TV of Pakistan
    3. Yosri Fouda of Al Jazeera of Qatar

    One would have expected Michael Sheuer to claim the $50 million bounty on the head of OBL. After all Mike was the head of the CIA unit that was tracking OBL. Mike also has written extensively about OBL. However it looks like Morgan Spurlock, of Super Size me fame may have discovered the most wanted man in the world. Internet bloggers are claiming that Spurlock has tracked down the “holy grail”. Is it Osama bin Laden?  He has succeeded where Mr. Bush, Mr. Musharraf and Mr. Karzai have failed.  The whisper about OBL and Spurlock is now a crescendo on the blogs–also covered by  MSNBC. It is possible, perhaps probable and definitely not inconceivable that Spurlock was granted an interview with the nemesis of Mr. Bush—OBL himself. The CIA officials are not saying anything on this story.

    The buzz at the Berlin Film Festival in February was that the book and movies rights to OBL and his interview. Stay tuned!  

    The “war on terrorism,” focused primarily on a fictional global insurgency named “al Qaida,” that, in fact, fought for American interests in Afghanistan, Bosnia, Croatia and Chechnya is an exercise in hypocrisy. The more “evidence” that is provided to us, to prove the al Qaida connection to every act of terrorism, the more evident it becomes that the war is a fraud, based on a cover-up of a treasonous attack, intended to whitewash history and to paint America as a heroic nation, dedicated to bringing freedom and democracy to all people. The United States’ claim to be promoting democracy, while it exports state terrorism, has demolished the hopes of all those who still believe in American “good will,” all over the world.

    osama-bin-laden-hideoutInformed people all over the world cannot fathom how the American administration can seriously claim to be pursuing “al Qaida-connected terrorists,” when they know that “al Qaida,” the terrorist organization never existed. Thanks to revelations by British MP Robin Cook in the Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/terrorism/story/0,12780,1523838,00.html and French intelligence agent Pierre-Henry Bunel at the Wayne Madsen Report, http://globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=viewArticle&code=BUN20051120&articleId=1291 people know that when the United States needed a new enemy, after the demise of the Soviet empire, they decided to call “the base” (an international computer data base in Saudi Arabia of Afghan fighters), designated as “al Qaida” [an email address], an international terrorist network.

    “Bin Laden was, though, a product of a monumental miscalculation by western security agencies. Throughout the 80s he was armed by the CIA and funded by the Saudis to wage jihad against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan. Al-Qaida, literally “the database”, was originally the computer file of the thousands of mujahideen who were recruited and trained with help from the CIA to defeat the Russians.” – Robin Cook


    us_map“The truth is, there is no Islamic army or terrorist group called Al Qaida. And any informed intelligence officer knows this. But there is a propaganda campaign to make the public believe in the presence of an identified entity representing the ‘devil’ only in order to drive the ‘TV watcher’ to accept a unified international leadership for a war against terrorism. The country behind this propaganda is the US and the lobbyists for the US war on terrorism are only interested in making money.” – Pierre-Henry Bunel

    “Elements associated with al Qaida” has become the new official catch-all phrase, used as often as possible, to incite terror among the American people and to justify new attacks by American forces and American-supported militia groups. We are going into Pakistan in force, to train new Pakistanis to fight other Pakistanis that we had trained too well in the past. How will we separate the “friendly” al Qaida from the unfriendly ones, when we bundle the whole bunch together under the rubric “al Qaida?”

    Why are Islamists like Ayman al Zawahiri considered al Q., after they provided the US Islamic fighters in Bosnia, Kosovo, and Macedonia, as well other Islamic recruits who served US interests in Chechnya?

    Osama Bin Laden dead or alive on cnnhttp://www.bestcyrano.org/THOMASPAINE/?p=143 The Islamic mercenaries were fighting for us when the embassies were bombed in Kenya and Tanzania in 1998, even after bin Laden and Zawahiri announced the establishment of “The International Islamic Front for Holy War Against Jews and Crusaders,” (an umbrella organization linking Islamic extremists in scores of countries around the world, the bin Laden group that was renamed Al Qaida). The militant group, now called al Qaeda was the instant answer to the 9/11 attacks, even though it was never what it was alleged to be, the ultimate terrorist bogeyman. The conjunction of US and al Qaida interests all over the Muslim world should warn thinking individuals, whenever attacks happen to occur in just the places that the neocon war planners would most like to invade.

    It is more than reasonable to question where al Qaida ends and the secret world of their CIA trainers begins. Was it other trained al Qaida agents who pre-planted the demolitions that brought the towers down, obtained US security codes, timed the attacks into ongoing war games and stood down fighter cover, or was that part of the act of war the CIA’s domain? Questioning further along that line, was Pakistan’s ISI (secret service) still acting as the CIA’s surrogate, when ISI head General Mahmud Ahmad allegedly had Sheik Omar wire Mohammed Atta $100,000? According to Chossudovsky:

    “The FBI had information on the money trail. They knew exactly who was financing the terrorists. Less than two weeks later, the findings of the FBI were confirmed by Agence France Presse (AFP) and the Times of India, quoting an official Indian intelligence report (which had been dispatched to Washington). According to these two reports, the money used to finance the 9-11 attacks had allegedly been “wired to WTC hijacker Mohammed Atta from Pakistan, by Ahmad Umar Sheikh, at the instance of [ISI Chief] General Mahmoud [Ahmad].” 10 According to the AFP (quoting the intelligence source):

    “The evidence we have supplied to the U.S. is of a much wider range and depth than just one piece of paper linking a rogue general to some misplaced act of terrorism.” http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php?context=viewArticle&code=CHO20020620&articleId=371
    The name “Sheikh Omar” should set off alarms to those who are paying attention. He was the one who Bhutto fingered on the David Frost interview on 2nd November 2007 (2:15), “Omar Sheikh, the man who murdered Osama bin Laden.” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UnychOXj9Tg Omar is mentioned in connection with a man that Bhutto feared might be involved in threats against her.

    President Musharraf, in his book In the Line of Fire stated that the Sheikh was originally recruited by British intelligence agency, MI6 to go to the Balkans. Here is another shadowy figure linked to al Qaida, Western intelligence agencies and the US program, organized by Bill Clinton, to bring radical Islamist Jihadis to the war in Yugoslavia. They fought on the US side, in a war prosecuted by the United States, as an Islamic paramilitary force. The Grassy knoll by Peter Chamberlin

    Noticias de Rupia | Nouvelles de Roupie | Rupiennachrichten | новости рупии | 卢比新闻 | Roepienieuws | Rupi Nyheter | ルピーニュース | Notizie di Rupia | PAKISTAN LEDGER | پاکستاني کھاتا | RUPEE NEWS | February 19th, 2009 | Moin Ansari | معین آنصآرّی | اخبار روپیہ |

    map(U.C.L.A./Thomas Gillespie) By using biogeographic principles to analyze the mountainous region around Osama bin Laden’s last known location, Tora Bora in Afghanistan, researchers suggest he’s most likely to be across the Pakistani border in the nearby town of Parachinar . (Click on the image to see a full-size map.)

    Where’s Osama? Using principles for predicting the distribution of wildlife, geographers at U.C.L.A. have identified what they say is the most logical hiding place for Osama bin Laden: Parachinar, a town in the mountains of Pakistan south of the Khyber Pass. And they’ve even identified the most likely buildings in town.

    It seems hard to believe this possibility hasn’t occurred to the many officials looking for Mr. bin Laden, but then, I find it it hard to believe they haven’t caught him already. I’ve spent a little time in the mountains and tribal areas of northwest Pakistan, and they struck me as oddly difficult places to hide. For all their ruggedness and remoteness, the mountainous areas had a small-town quality to them: the locals kept track of one another and of any intruders. Even if one clan gave Mr. bin Laden sanctuary and could be bribed to keep his secret, his presence could easily become known to a rival clan in the next valley.

    So why hasn’t anyone claimed the $50 million bounty on his head? One possible answer, assuming that Mr. Bin Laden is still in the mountains, is that the locals don’t know how to collect the reward or don’t believe it will be paid (and indeed the bureaucracy of the reward can be daunting). Another answer is that the Westerners pursuing Mr. Bin Laden have so few contacts that they still haven’t figured out whom to talk to or where to go — in which case they might take a look at the study in the new issue of M.I.T. International Review by a team of researchers led by Thomas W. Gillespie, a professor of geography at U.C.L.A. and an expert on measuring biodiversity from space. The researchers draw on two aspects of the island biogeographic theory for predicting distribution of wildlife:

    Distance-decay theory states that as one goes further away from a precise location, there is an exponential decline in the turnover of species and a lower probability of finding the same composition of species. The theory of island biogeography states that large and close islands will have higher immigration rates and support more species with lower extinction rates than small isolated islands.

    These theories can be applied over varying spatial scales to posit bin Laden’s current location based on his last reputed geographic location. Distance-decay theory would predict that he is closest to the point where he was last reported and, by extension, within a region that has a similar physical environment and cultural composition (that is, similar religious and political beliefs).

    By that reasoning, the researchers assume that Mr. bin Laden is likely to be in a relatively large town close to his last publicly reported location, the Tora Bora caves in eastern Afghanistan.

    “Island biology theory predicts that he would find his way to the largest but least isolated city of that area,” Dr. Gillespie said. “If you get stuck on an island, you would want it to be Hawaii rather than one with a single palm tree. It’s a matter of resources.” While many have assumed Mr. bin Laden is living in a cave, the researchers say that his need for resources — electricity for a dialysis machine, food and lodging for his bodyguards — makes a town more likely.

    After analyzing satellite images of the terrain and the amount of nighttime light in the area surrounding area, they identify the town of Parachinar, 12 miles from Tora Bora, as the most likely hiding spot because it’s the largest and fourth-least isolated among the towns in the region. And although satellite photos reveal more than 1,000 structures in that town, the researchers narrowed the possibilities to a short list by assuming that Mr. bin Laden needs a hiding place with at least three rooms, high ceilings (he’s 6-foot-4) and a 9-foot protective wall.

    “If he’s still alive, he honestly could be sitting there right now,” said Thomas W. Gillespie, the study’s lead author and an associate professor of geography at UCLA. “It is still the safest tribal area and city in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas of northwest Pakistan and one of the only tribal areas that the U.S. has not bombed with its unmanned Predators.”

    The researchers urge U.S. officials to check out the buildings and warn that if the Taliban takes over the much larger city of Peshawar (at the entrance to the Khyber Pass), Mr. bin Laden could flee there and be much harder to find. They also urge officials to apply these geographic techniques if there are any more sightings of Mr. bin Laden anywhere else. (It’s been suggested that he has fled the mountains for the outlaw territory of Yemen or Somalia.)

    “We believe our work represents the first scientific approach to establishing bin Laden’s current location,” said John A. Agnew, a co-author of the study and a U.C.L.A. geography professor. “The methods are repeatable and could easily be updated with new information obtained by the U.S. intelligence community.”

    Could geographers really have a better chance than spies of tracking down the world’s most wanted fugitive? And does anyone else care to suggest where he might be? There is that $50 million prize . . . .New York Times.  Geographers Find bin Laden — Theoretically By John Tierney

    Appendix A

    MIT International Review | web.mit.edu/mitir
    Web-published essay installment for 17 February 2009
    Finding Osama bin Laden: An Application of Biogeographic Theories and Satellite Imagery
    Thomas W. Gillespie and John A. Agnew are professors of geography at UCLA. They may be contacted respectively at tg@geog.ucla.edu and jagnew@geog.ucla.edu. Erika Mariano, Scott Mossler, Nolan Jones, Matt Braughton, and Jorge Gonzalez are undergraduates in UCLA’s geography department. They may be contacted respectively at erikmari@ucla.edu, smossler@ucla.edu, nolanjones@ucla.edu, mbraught@ucla.edu, and jorgon@ucla.edu.1

    Abstract
    One of the most important political questions of our time is: Where is Osama bin Laden? We use biogeographic theories associated with the distribution of life and extinction (distance-decay theory, island biogeography theory, and life history characteristics) and remote sensing data (Landsat ETM+, Shuttle Radar Topography Mission, Defense Meteorological Satellite, QuickBird) over three spatial scales (global, regional, local) to identify where bin Laden is most probably currently located. We believe that our work involves the first scientific approach to establishing his current location. The methods are repeatable and can be updated with new information obtained from the US intelligence community.

    1 The authors would like to thank Chase Langford for his assistance with graphics. The California Center for Population Research, UCLA provided funding through the Spatial Demography Program. We would also like to thank Bill Clark, Kathy Deuel, Rebecca Goodine, Patrick Healy, Stephanie Pincetl, and Duccio Rocchini, for reviewing this manuscript. We also thank the reviewers and editor for insightful comments and suggestions.
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 1 of 17

    Introduction
    Osama bin Laden remains at large. Thought to be isolated from al-Qaeda’s daily operations, bin Laden’s direction may no longer be a relevant factor in the group’s effectiveness. Yet the image of the bearded demagogue remains a source of inspiration to enemies of the West. Where is he? In his confirmation hearings before the Senate Intelligence Committee, then-CIA Director-designate Leon Panetta emphasized the hunt for Osama bin Laden as a top priority for the new administration (1). He remains the FBI’s most wanted terrorist. A number of al Qaeda commanders have been captured or killed, including Mohammed Atef, Mohammad Saleh, Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, and Abu Zubaydah. And yet despite seven years of espionage and a $25 million reward for his capture, the mystery of bin Laden’s whereabouts persists (2). Perhaps the CIA has availed itself of every gizmo, gadget, and theory the world has ever known to bring bin Laden to justice. The public, on the other hand, has never seemed to engage wholeheartedly in the debate over the manhunt; nor, to our knowledge, has the scientific community offered up any testable hypotheses on the subject. In informal conversations in the Geography Department at UCLA, we began to ask ourselves if the biogeographic theories we use every day – theories that predict how plants and animals distribute themselves over space and over time – employed in conjunction with publicly available satellite imagery, could shed some light on this question. The outcomes of this musing, presented below, are our thoughts and experiment. By bringing these methodologies to bear, it is our hope that a long overdue debate might bring bin Laden back to the fore of the public consciousness – and possibly to justice. True to the scientific method, a biogeographer starts with the best information available, makes a set of assumptions, and employs theories and technologies to home in on a progressively testable hypothesis. There have been significant advances recently in biogeographic theory and remote sensing imagery that can be applied to provide testable propositions about bin Laden’s current location (3-4). Distance-decay theory and island biogeography theory are two biogeographic theories associated with the distribution of life and extinction that can be used to identify the location of bin Laden at global and regional spatial scales. Distance-decay theory states that as one goes further away from a precise location, there is an exponential decline in the turnover of species and a lower probability of finding the same composition of species (5-7). The theory of island biogeography states that large and close islands will have higher immigration rates and support more species with lower extinction rates than small isolated islands (8-9).
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 2 of 17

    These theories can be applied over varying spatial scales to posit bin Laden’s current location based on his last reputed geographic location. Distance-decay theory would predict that he is closest to the point where he was last reported and, by extension, within a region that has a similar physical environment and cultural composition (that is, similar religious and political beliefs). For instance, the further he moves from his last reported location into the more secular parts of Pakistan or into India, the greater the probability that he will find himself in different cultural surroundings, thereby increasing the probability of his being captured or eliminated. Island biogeographic theory predicts that bin Laden is in a larger town rather than a smaller and more isolated town where extinction rate would be higher. Finally, high-resolution analyses of a city can be undertaken to identify individual buildings that match bin Laden’s life history characteristics. For example, he reportedly has a small entourage of body guards, requiring a structure that contains at least three rooms. (See Table 1 for a complete list of life history characteristics used to derive structural building requirements.) The public also now has at its disposal a number of new remote sensing tools to put these theories into action to create testable hypotheses. There have been over 73 successful launches of earth-observation satellites between 2000 and 2007. Most of these satellites can be utilized by scientists to examine natural and man-made features on the earth’s surface. Although these satellites and sensors are not as high resolution as US intelligence satellites, some may be accurate enough to create working hypotheses on bin Laden’s current whereabouts.

    Methods
    Three spatial scale analyses (global, regional, local) were examined to identify bin Laden’s likeliest current location (10). Osama bin Laden was last seen by non-local observers in Jalalabad, Afghanistan on November 13, 2001 and, according to radio traffic, he was last heard from in a transmission from Tora Bora on November 28, 2001 (Figure 1) (11). At a global scale, we used his last known location (Tora Bora) to create distance-decay probability maps over satellite imagery (Figure 2). At a regional scale, we overlaid the distance-decay map on the city islands to identify cities with the highest probability of bin Laden’s occurrence based on island biogeography theory. At a local spatial scale, we systematically searched the city with the highest probability of occurrence – that is, the highest probability of hosting bin Laden –to identify structures that match his six life history characteristics (see Table 1). Details on all satellite imagery and method used are in Appendix 1.
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 3 of 17

    TABLE 1: LIFE HISTORY CHARACTERISTICS OF OSAMA BIN LADEN AND ASSOCIATED PHYSICAL STRUCTURE ATTRIBUTES
    Life History Characteristics
    Physical Structure Attribute
    Is 6’4” tall
    Tall building
    Requires a dialysis machine that uses electricity
    Electric grid hookup or generator
    Prefers physical protection
    Walls over three meters high
    Enjoys personal privacy
    Space between structures
    Retains a small number of body guards
    More than three rooms
    Prefers to remain protected from aerial view
    Trees for cover when outside

    When we applied a distance-decay model to his last known location from 2001, the FATA – or Federally Administered Tribal Area – of Kurram had the highest probability of hosting bin Laden (98%) (Figure 3). There were 26 city islands within a 20-km radius of his last known location in northwestern Kurram. Parachinar figured as the largest and the fourth-least isolated city (Figure 4). Nightlight imagery also shows that Parachinar is the closest city to his last known location and by far the brightest city by nightlight intensity in Kurram (Figure 5). When we undertook a systematic building search in the city of Parachinar, this approach resulted in three structures that meet all six of them (Figure 6) and 16 structures that meet five of them.

    The Global Scale
    There are few published reports concerning bin Laden’s current global or regional location. One comes from a letter from Atiyah Abd al-Rahman to Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, bin Laden’s presumed second-in-command, dated December 11, 2005 (12). It suggests that he and the al-Qaeda leadership were based in the Waziristan region of Pakistan at the time. However, it is difficult to believe that a letter would be written by such a high-ranking official giving away bin Laden’s location. Another alternative hypothesis is that he resides in the southern or northern FATAs where there is significantly greater Taliban (Afghan and Pakistani) military activity.
    At a global scale, distance-decay theory suggests that Osama bin Laden’s current location is not likely to be random, and his probability of occurrence exponentially decreases the further he moves from his last known location (5-7). Our results based on his last know location in 2001 indicate that there is a 98% probability that he is in Kurram, Pakistan, and an 86.6% probability that he is within one of the seven FATAs. The FATAs have long been outside of central government control and served as reservoirs of militant Islamists working to

    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al. MIT International Review Page 4 of 17
    change the governments in both Kabul and Islamabad since the 1970s. Based on his last known location in Tora Bora, we estimate that he must have traveled 3.1 km over an approximately 4,000 meter pass in winter to enter Kurram, Pakistan. Doing so would have been extremely difficult for a 44-year old man with diabetes. Kurram is surrounded on three sides by the Afghan border (known as the Durand Line), which essentially cuts right though the ethnically Pushtun belt that straddles it. It is unlikely that he would have headed back into Afghanistan after leaving Tora Bora, if only because doing so would have required him to abandon the mountains for more open countryside.

    The Regional Scale
    Parachinar has a long history of housing mujahideen during the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in the 1980s, so it most likely contains a large number of Taliban soldiers who cross over from here into Afghanistan. Residing near or in a large city should reduce bin Laden’s chances of exposure and elimination due to a military raid on a small city or an isolated structure. Smaller cities would greatly reduce his security and privacy, and there are only a small number of structures that appear well-protected in smaller towns (Figure 7). Nightlight imagery also reveals that Parachinar is one of the brightest cities in the FATAs after the city of Miram Shah in North Waziristan, which is 102.3 km away. Most cities there have little or no nightlight signature. The city of Peshawar has the brightest nightlight signature in the region and may soon fall to the Taliban. If Peshawar falls under Taliban control, the search for bin Laden will become significantly more difficult due to the large number of structures in that city compared to the relatively small number of structures overall in the FATAs.

    The Local Scale
    Based on Osama bin Laden’s life history characteristics, three buildings should be closely monitored to test the hypothesis that he is located at one of them. Structures A, B, and C are the best fortified and some of the largest residential homes or structures in the city of Parachinar. Structures A and C are residential homes, while structure B appears to be a prison. However, if it is a prison, it has one of the best-maintained gardens in all of Parachinar. There are also 16 structures that match five of bin Laden’s life history characteristics (Figure 6 and Table 2-1). If one follows our approach, one would predict that he is located in one of these three buildings. Alternatively, there is a popular perception that bin Laden is currently residing in a cave. A cave would have to have a sealed entrance, be heated and ventilated, and have supplies transported to the cave monthly or annually. We feel that most of these requirements would have
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 5 of 17


    physical manifestation that might easily be seen from space, and that the cave hypothesis is unlikely but could be tested.
    Conclusions and Implications

    Our conclusion results from applying a model that, like all other models, makes critical assumptions. What we have attempted to demonstrate is that it is possible to narrow down where Osama bin Laden is by ruling out where he is unlikely to be and by providing a scalable hypothesis that can be tested, and accepted or rejected, like any other in science. High-resolution imagery of all structures in the FATAs is currently available from a number of international commercial satellites with a 0.4 meter pixel size; however, open-access satellite images can be high enough to be a national security risk in the region (13-14). For instance, in an attempt to aid disaster relief efforts after the October 8, 2005 earthquake in Kashmir, numerous international aid agencies posted high-resolution satellite images on the web. The Pakistani government forced these images to be removed because they feared that the security of the Kashmir region might be compromised. Perhaps it is past time to embrace this technology and create a public database concerning models or hypotheses about bin Laden’s current location. The US intelligence community has at least three agencies that have been involved in searching for bin Laden. The National Security Agency does code-breaking and communications monitoring, the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency makes maps and analyzes surveillance photographs, and the National Reconnaissance Office provides satellite imagery. Altogether, the US intelligence community spent over $50 billion on intelligence activities last year alone. Ideally, some of this money should have been spent looking for bin Laden and the US intelligence community could make public a report based on all data collected from 2001 to 2006. The three agencies mentioned above should also disprove the hypotheses that Osama bin Laden is: (1) located in the Kurram region of Pakistan, (2) located in the city of Parachinar, and (3) at one of the three hypothesized buildings. These methods are repeatable and could easily be updated with new information obtained from the US intelligence community on his last known location.

    End Notes
    1. Kean TH, Hamilton L (2004) The 9/11 Commission Report: Final Report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (W.W. Norton and Company, New York).
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 6 of 17
    2. Naughton, P (2009) Osama bin Laden calls for new jihad over Israeli offensive in Gaza. New York Times, 14 January 2009. 3. Nekola JC, Brown JH (2007) The wealth of species: ecological communities, complex systems and the legacy of Frank Preston. Ecology Letters 10:188-196. 4. Gillespie TW, Chu J, Frankenberg, E Thomas D (2007) Assessment and prediction of natural hazards from satellite imagery. Progress in Physical Geography 31:459-470. 5. Nekola JC, White PS (1999) The distance decay of similarity in biogeography and ecology. Journal of Biogeography 26:867-878. 6. Koleff P, Gaston KJ, Lennon JJ (2003) Measuring beta diversity for presence-absence data. Journal of Animal Ecology 72:367-382. 7. Rocchini D (2007) Distance decay in spectral space in analyzing ecosystem -diversity. International Journal of Remote Sensing 28:2635-2644. 8. MacArthur RH, Wilson EO (1967) The Theory of Island Biogeography (Princeton University Press, Princeton) 9. Hargis CD, Bissonette JA, David JL (1998) The behavior of landscape metrics commonly used in the study of habitat fragmentation. Landscape Ecology 13:167-186. 10. Willis KJ, Whittaker RJ (2002) Species diversity-scale matters. Science, 295:1245-1248. 11. Stewart J (2007) The Savage Border: The History of the North-West Frontier (Sutton Publishing Limited, Gloucestershire) 12. DeYoung K (2006) Letter gives glimpse of Al-Qaeda’s leadership. Washington Post, 2 October 2006. 13. Butler D (2005) Quake aid hampered by ban on web shots. Nature 437:1072-1073. 14. Nourbakhsh I, Sargent R (2006) Mapping disaster zones. Nature 439:787-788.

    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.

    MIT International Review Page 7 of 17
    Figures
    Figure 1. The last known location of Osama bin Laden in Tora Bora using two-dimensional spectral and three-dimensional spectral and elevation imagery
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.

    MIT International Review Page 8 of 17
    Figure 2. Exponential distance-decay model of bin Laden’s location with percent probability and distance
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 9 of 17
    Figure 3. Probability model of bin Laden’s current location based on distance-decay theory at a global spatial scale
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 10 of 17
    Figure 4. Regional analysis of city islands within a 20-km radius of bin Laden’s last known location (red dot)
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 11 of 17
    Figure 5. Regional analysis of city islands in Pakistan’s FATAs using nightlight imagery
    Figure 6. Three predicted locations of bin Laden based on his life history characteristics
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 12 of 17
    Structure A N 33.901944° E 70.093746°
    Structure B N 33.911694° E 70.0959°
    Structure C N 33.888207° E 70.113308°
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 13 of 17
    Figure 7. Small city islands and structures in Kurram, Pakistan
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 14 of 17
    Appendix 1: Satellite Imagery and Methods
    Satellite Imagery
    Landsat ETM+, Shuttle Radar Topography Mission, QuickBird, and Defense Meteorological Satellite Program-Operational Linescan System imagery were used to provide hypotheses on the current location of bin Laden. All imagery was georectified into the same geographic coordinate system (WGS84). Two Landsat 7 ETM+ images of Afghanistan and Pakistan with a pixel size of 30 m × 30 m were acquired from March 28, 2001 and September 22, 2002. Shuttle Radar Topography Mission data on elevation with a pixel size of 90 m × 90 m were acquired and combined with Landsat ETM+ imagery of the region. QuickBird imagery with a pixel size of 0.6 m × 0.6 m in the visible wavelengths was acquired via Google Earth for March 19, 2004 and November 12, 2007. Defense Meteorological Satellite Program-Operational Linescan System imagery under cloud-free and low moon conditions was collected for 2007.

    Data Analysis.
    Global Scale. A three-dimensional model of the Tora Bora landscape, using Landsat ETM+ and Shuttle Radar Topography Mission imagery, identified the point that bin Laden would have passed in Tora Bora based on spectral imagery and topography. A distance-decay model using an exponential curve was used with his last known location in Tora Bora (N 34.0641° E 70.1375°) set at 99% probability of bin Laden’s occurrence, and with the White House in Washington D.C., located 11, 246 kilometers away, set at 1% probability of bin Laden’s occurrence (N 38.8976° W 77.0366°) (Figure 1). We use a simple exponential model (P(d) = kd) where k is the constant derived from our assumed values of there being a 1% chance of Osama bin Laden being located in Washington, D.C. and a 99% chance that he is located in the area he was last seen, d is the distance from his last known location and P(d) is the resulting probability of his being located at that distance. Thus, we predict according to distance-decay theory that the further Osama bin Laden is from Tora Bora and the nearer he is to Washington, D.C. the lower the probability that he is located there. The resulting equation (P(d) = 0.99959058977238d) was then used to calculate individual values of probability given a certain distances.
    Regional scale. City islands larger than 100 m x 100 m were digitized over geo-referenced QuickBird imagery in ArcGIS 9.0 to quantify area and isolation metrics. City-islands were quantified as area of continuous man-made structures and the distance in kilometers to all other city-islands was used as an
    17 Feb 2009

     

     

     

    FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 15 of 17
    isolation metric (9). Boundaries of the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATAs) were overlaid on nightlight imagery to identify city islands in the region. Local scale. QuickBird imagery of the city with the highest probability of occurrence – that is, the highest probability of having bin Laden – was systematically searched across 1 km × 1 km grids to identify structures that match his six life history characteristics (Table 1). Each structure was quantified as 1 or 0 for accommodating each one of these six characteristics. Structure values were summed and the highest values (for example 5 or 6) were selected as his probable location.
    17 Feb 2009 FINDING OSAMA BIN LADEN Gillespie et al.
    MIT International Review Page 16 of 17
    Appendix 2: Coordinates
    Table 2-1. Seven 1 km × 1 km grids in Parachinar, structure number within grid, and location of structures with a score of five and six based on the sum of physical structure attributes fitting bin Laden’s life history characteristics Source: The authors
    Grid #
    Structure
    Score
    Latitude
    Longitude
    1
    1
    5
    33.903432°
    70.091091°
    2
    6
    33.901944°
    70.093746°
    3
    5
    33.902662°
    70.095839°
    2
    1
    5
    33.899715°
    70.104956°
    2
    5
    33.900707°
    70.103338°
    3
    5
    33.906885°
    70.105129°
    4
    5
    33.896283°
    70.111935°
    3
    1
    5
    33.898657°
    70.116777°
    2
    5
    33.899745°
    70.118473°
    3
    5
    33.894525°
    70.121523°
    4
    1
    5
    33.897951°
    70.089383°
    2
    5
    33.898255°
    70.087519°
    5
    1
    5
    33.892353°
    70.106461°
    2
    5
    33.887763°
    70.111442°
    6
    1
    5
    33.885623°
    70.115935°
    2
    5
    33.891417°
    70.114477°
    3
    6
    33.888207°
    70.113308°
    7
    1
    6
    33.911694°
    70.095900°
    2
    5
    33.913399°
    70.097189°

     

    Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,  

    We would like to refer our readers to the an article on “Toppling the US military” that is worth its weight in gold. Search for it on this site. See: “Kissinger threatened Zulifiqar Ali Bhutto”

    Progressive BloggersPakistani Bloggers

    Filed under: Current Affairs, Pak CA, Poli Sci, Politics, Reli & Pol., US Int Rel., US Poli | Tagged: , , ,

    « »

    One Response

    1. SPP, on July 28th, 2008 at 7:28 am Said:

      The robbed that smiles, steals something from the thief.WilliamShakespeareWilliam Shakespeare

      Reply

    Leave a Reply